Performance Analysis
It's not a particularly rosy picture when it comes to thermals with the PC-Q28, but given the focus on aesthetics rather than airflow that doesn't come as a big surprise. The CPU delta T of 53°C isn't the highest on test - that crown goes to the
Cooler Master Elite 120 Advanced and
Fractal Design Node 304 using its lowest fan speed setting - however it's considerably warmer than the Prodigy and
Silverstone Sugo SG08, which were both 10°C cooler at least.
Click to enlarge
The GPU delta T was even worse, with only the Lian Li PC-TU200 putting in a worse result. This again isn't a huge surprise, given the limited intake vent, cramped interior and proximity of the graphics card cooler to the bottom of the case but it's disappointing nonetheless. By comparison the BitFenix Prodigy performed much better here, thanks to ample room to hide cables, plenty of vents and the fact the GPU isn't in a cramped, confined space.
Click to enlarge
Conclusion
Despite often average cooling results, Lian Li's cases still continue to be popular amongst general enthusiasts and modders alike. We have to admit that despite the mediocre results on show here with the PC-Q28, its build quality, flexibility and sheer elegance are hard to ignore. It really does look exquisite on the outside, which will no doubt win the usual people over.
However, getting our professional hats on, the price (assuming it does hit the shelves at the prices we've listed) and cooling really aren't very competitive. The likes of the
Prodigy and SilverStone
Fortress FT03-Mini are cheaper and offer much better cooling, with the Prodigy also offering fantastic support for all things water-cooled.
While much of this is down to size (the PC-Q28 is much smaller than both these cases), in this light, it's difficult to recommend the PC-Q28 for high-end system owners - the cooling on offer isn't really up to scratch and you system will be hotter and noisier than it would be if it was housed in a number of alternatives. However for low to medium-end systems, its cooling will be much more at home, and you can gaze lovingly at the gorgeous exterior without worrying about your hardware cooking itself.
Want to comment? Please log in.